Marc Bartra's timed run wrongfoots Real Madrid
Betis defender Marc Bartra says he deliberately timed his run into the box on Mbappé's saved penalty, a trick that would fail under IFAB's incoming 2026/27 encroachment rule.
Marc Bartra says his run into the box after Kylian Mbappé's penalty was no accident. The Betis defender was already blocking the rebound before Álvaro Vallés had even finished saving the spot-kick that decided Friday's 1-0 win at La Cartuja, and Real Madrid's players immediately protested that he had encroached.
Bartra told Movistar Plus he had checked the rule with a contact from the refereeing world after seeing another player try the same thing weeks earlier.
Bartra said.
Mundo Deportivo reported that Bartra timed his run so precisely that half a second either way would have caught him inside the area before Mbappé struck the ball. Under the current Laws of the Game, an airborne player is not judged to have entered the box until his feet touch the ground, and VAR waved play on.
Yahoo Sports has since pointed out that IFAB's 2026/27 Laws change that calculation. Under the new wording, an airborne player's position is judged by where his feet would land if he were touching the ground, and a save followed by defensive encroachment that has an impact on the ball can now trigger a retake. On that reading, Bartra's projected landing spot — and his touch on the rebound — would have been enough to send Mbappé back to the spot, months before the rule takes effect.
The result leaves Mourinho's Real Madrid without a win at La Cartuja, beaten by Troy Parrott's late strike and Vallés's save, after Betis also had an Espí goal disallowed during the game.
Whether referees start applying that stricter reading of encroachment once the new law is in force is the open question. Had it applied on Friday, by all accounts Bartra's calculated dash would have cost Betis the points rather than won them.
About this article
Prepared by the editorial team with the help of algorithms, based on the sources listed
Sources 24
- A mad penalty: Mbappé missed, Valles celebrated and Bartra moved early? sports.yahoo.com
- El motivo por el que no se repitió el penalti a favor del Real Madrid ante el Betis mundodeportivo.com
- Бартра про пенальти в матче с «Реалом»: «Знакомый арбитр объяснил мне: если опорная нога в воздухе, то пенальти не перебивается. Если бы я задержался немного дольше, то оказался бы в штрафной» sports.ru
- Бартра про пенальти в матче с «Реалом»: «Знакомый арбитр объяснил мне: если нога в воздухе, пенальти не перебивается. Все получилось» sports.ru
- Судья ошибся против «Реала»? Разгорелись жаркие споры euro-football.ru
- Бартра: «Я сам спросил у судьи об эпизоде с пенальти Мбаппе» euro-football.ru
- Технический комитет судей подтвердил, что Мбаппе не должен был перебивать пенальти euro-football.ru
- Mbappe penalty controversy explained: Why Marc Bartra’s movement did not lead to a retake sports.yahoo.com
- El 'truco' de Bartra que le salió de lujo en el penalti de Mbappé mundodeportivo.com
- El CTA considera un acierto no repetir el penalti de Mbappé mundodeportivo.com
- New IFAB rule proves Mbappe’s penalty should have been retaken during Betis vs Real Madrid sports.yahoo.com
- CTA considers referee decision to not retake Mbappe’s penalty vs Real Betis was right sports.yahoo.com
- Xavier Estrada Fernández estalla contra el CTA: "¿Podéis aprender la regla y no hacer el ridículo?" mundodeportivo.com
- Betis-uitblinker Valles bestudeerde Mbappé en kreeg hulp door trucje Bartra vi.nl
- Комитет судей Испании подержал решение не перебивать пенальти «Реала» в матче с «Бетисом». Одна нога Бартры осталась на земле, вторая была в воздухе sports.ru
- Matías Prats, contundente con el arbitraje español: "Ellos mismos no son capaces de ponerse de acuerdo" sport.es
- Моуринью о судействе с «Бетисом»: «Почему не перебили пенальти? Может, потому что ВАР не знает правил, а может, не хотели этого делать. Почему судью не позвали к монитору? Странно» sports.ru
- El CTA tiene claro que no debió repetirse el penalti de Mbappé mundodeportivo.com
- Моуринью озвучил претензии: «Я хочу, чтобы судьи ответили на это» euro-football.ru
- 'Tiempo de Revisión' también dará la razón al penalti de la Cartuja mundodeportivo.com
- 'Tiempo de Revisión' es categórico en el acierto del penalti de La Cartuja mundodeportivo.com
- Mourinho perguntou e Comité de Árbitros respondeu: «Penálti de Mbappé não era para repetir» record.pt
- Моуринью ответили на претензию по судейству euro-football.ru
- Bartra: "Eran imágenes manipuladas" mundodeportivo.com