Orlando City and Atletico San Luis played out a 2-2 draw in the League Cup group stage before Orlando City won the penalty shootout. The match took place on 12 August 2026, and Orlando City advanced after the visitors could not convert from the spot.
D. Dike opened the scoring for Orlando City in the 31st minute. J. Ellis doubled the lead for the hosts in the 69th minute before S. Perez pulled one back for Atletico San Luis in the 79th minute. D. Rodriguez then scored twice in stoppage time, first in the 90th minute and again in the 90+7th minute, to complete the 2-2 draw.
There were plenty of substitutions as both sides reshuffled. Orlando City brought on M. Pasalic in the 46th minute, D. Dike was replaced in the 59th minute, and L. Flores came on in the 68th minute. Atletico San Luis made four changes in the 77th minute, including bringing on W. Cartagena and M. Garcia.
Orlando City were more efficient in front of goal. They registered 7 shots on target with 54 per cent accuracy to produce 4 goals in regular time. Atletico San Luis had 61 per cent possession but could only find the net once from 5 shots on target at 28 per cent accuracy.
The penalty shootout followed the draw. Orlando City scored all five of their spot-kicks, while Atletico San Luis missed one attempt. The result gives Orlando City maximum points from their opening group stage fixture.